Whipped Goat Cheese Crostini with Figs and Prosciutto

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

This whipped goat cheese crostini is topped with warm honey thyme figs, salty prosciutto and crunchy pistachios on crisp toasted bread. It’s an easy fall appetizer and one very good reason to grab those fresh figs while they’re in season.

Whipped goat cheese crostini's topped with fresh figs, honey butter sauce, fresh thyme and prosciutto on a cutting board.

The goat cheese is whipped until creamy, while the fresh figs get a quick simmer in butter, honey and thyme, just enough to soften them and bring out their sweetness. Layer everything onto toasted baguette with prosciutto and finish with a drizzle of that warm honey thyme butter from the pan.

It’s creamy, tangy, sweet and salty with plenty of crunch from the crostini. Best of all, most of it can be prepped ahead, which makes it a great appetizer for a fall dinner party.

So…What’s My Fig Story?

I almost always have a story behind a recipe.

Something my Nanny made, like her stuffed artichokes. A recipe from my dad’s handwritten notebook. Something I ate somewhere that I came home determined to recreate.

This one? Nothing. Zip.

I kept walking past these gorgeous figs at my local farmers market until I finally caved and thought, I need to actually do something with these.

Technically I SHOULD have a fig story. We actually had a fig tree in the backyard growing up on Long Island. Go ahead, picture it. Baskets of sun warmed figs, some cherished family recipe born right there in the yard.

Nope.

What I remember is my dad picking exactly one fig. One. Every other fig on that tree was already colonized by an army of tiny black ants. Figs did not play a starring role in my childhood, and that’s basically the entire saga. So maybe I’m making up for lost time.

Let’s Fig-ure This Recipe Out Together

Sorry. Had to. There’s nothing complicated happening here, but each layer brings something different to the crostini. Crisp bread, creamy whipped goat cheese, warm sweet figs and salty prosciutto.

Here’s what you’ll need.

Ingredients for Whipped Goat Cheese Crostini

All the ingredients in a whipped goat cheese crostini on a wooden surface with white text next to each ingredient.

Baguette: Slice it thinly into rounds so you get a crisp base that’s sturdy enough to hold all those toppings. Brush the slices lightly with olive oil before toasting.
Goat cheese: The whole base of this operation. Let it soften a bit before whipping so it becomes nice and creamy.
Crème fraîche: Just enough to loosen the goat cheese and give it an extra smooth, creamy texture without taking away that little tang I love. If you can’t find crème fraîche at your local market, no worries, just use cream cheese.
Olive oil: You’ll use some for brushing the baguette and a little in the whipped goat cheese. Let’s use a good quality olive oil for this recipe since there are so few ingredients.
Honey: A touch goes into the whipped goat cheese, and we’ll use more with the figs. It balances the tanginess of the cheese without making the crostini overly sweet.
Fresh figs: The star of the show. Black Mission, Brown Turkey or whatever beautiful ripe figs you can find will work here.
Butter: This becomes the base of that warm honey thyme sauce for the figs.
Fresh thyme: I love thyme with figs. A few fresh sprigs gently flavor the butter and honey while the figs cook. And more for garnish.
Prosciutto: That salty bite is exactly what all that creamy goat cheese and honey needs. Tear it into smaller ribbons rather than piling an entire slice onto each crostini.
Salt and black pepper: A little of both goes into the whipped goat cheese. Remember that the goat cheese and prosciutto are already salty, so taste as you go.
Pistachios, optional: If you want some extra crunch, sprinkle chopped toasted pistachios over the finished crostini. I love them here, but they’re completely optional.
Fresh garlic, optional: If you like a little garlic in the background, cut a clove in half and rub it over the crostini while the bread is still warm.

How to Make Whipped Goat Cheese Crostini

1. Toast the Crostini

Slice the baguette into rounds that are thin enough to crisp up, but they need to be sturdy enough to hold the toppings, with a nice crisp texture.

Arrange them on a baking sheet. Lightly brush each piece with olive oil and toast until crisp and lightly golden.

If you’re using the optional garlic, rub a cut garlic clove over the bread while it’s still warm

Baguette sliced into rounds on a cutting board for the whipped goat cheese crostini.

2. Make the Whipped Goat Cheese

Add the softened goat cheese, crème fraîche, a drizzle of olive oil, honey, salt and black pepper to a food processor.

Whip until completely smooth and creamy, scraping down the sides as needed.

Give it a taste. You want the tang of the goat cheese to still come through, with just a little sweetness from the honey.

Whipped goat cheese in a food processor.

3. Sauté the Fresh Figs

Melt the butter in a cast-iron skillet or sauté pan over medium low heat. Add the honey and fresh thyme and let everything come together.

Add the halved figs, cut side down, and sauté for just 1 to 2 minutes, until they’re warmed through and beginning to soften. That’s it.

Fresh figs are delicate, and we’re not looking to cook them down. You want them to hold their shape while picking up all that buttery honey thyme flavor. Remove the figs carefully from the pan. And don’t you dare wash that pan yet. But you can discard the sprigs.

Fresh figs sautéing in a cast iron skillet with butter, honey and thyme sprigs.

4. Start Layering

Spread each toasted baguette round generously with whipped goat cheese. Top with a warm fig half and a ribbon of prosciutto.

Then take that warm honey thyme butter still hanging out in the sauté pan and drizzle a little over each crostini. That’s the good stuff.

Finish with a few fresh thyme leaves and toasted pistachio nuts if you’d like.

A finished whipped goat cheese crostini topped with prosciutto, thyme sprigs and pistachios.

Make Ahead Tips for Entertaining

You know I love an appetizer I can get mostly finished before anyone walks through the door.

The whipped goat cheese can be made ahead and refrigerated. Take it out a little before assembling so it’s creamy and easy to spread.

The baguette slices can also be toasted ahead of time. Once they’re completely cool, keep them at room temperature so they stay crisp.

I would save the figs for closer to serving. (Unless you’re skipping the sauté altogether). They only take a minute or two in the pan, and I love the contrast of the slightly warm figs against the creamy goat cheese.

Then assemble the crostini shortly before serving so the bread stays crisp.

A little work ahead of time, a couple of minutes at the stove and onto the platter they go.

Now go pour the cocktails.

Switch It Up: Easy Crostini Variations

Once you’ve got the basic idea, there are plenty of ways to play around with these. Use what you have, leave off what you don’t love, or make a few different versions for the same platter.

Keep the figs fresh. Skip the sauté altogether and top the whipped goat cheese with sliced or halved ripe figs and a drizzle of honey.
Switch up the cheese. Try whipped ricotta or whipped feta, or keep things really easy with a soft, spreadable Brie.
Fresh figs nowhere to be found? Use fig jam or preserves instead. Spread a little fig jam on the toasted baguette, top with whipped goat cheese and carry on.
Add balsamic. A light drizzle of balsamic glaze adds a sweet, tangy finish that works beautifully with the figs and goat cheese.
Skip the prosciutto. Leave it off for a vegetarian version. There’s already plenty happening here without it.
Toast those nuts. If you’re adding pistachios, give them a quick toast first for even more crunch and flavor.
Try another nut. Walnuts, pecans or hazelnuts would all work well in place of the pistachios.
Make it garlicky. Rub a cut garlic clove over the toasted baguette while it’s still warm, then pile everything on top.
Skip the bread altogether. Use a crisp apple or pear slice as your base, add the whipped goat cheese and fig, then wrap or drape a little prosciutto around it. I love a tart, crisp apple here to balance all that creamy, sweet and salty goodness.

Whipped goat cheese with fresh figs layered on top of an apple slice, wrapped in prosciutto and drizzled with balsamic glaze and honey.

All the Figgy Details (FAQ’s)

How do I know when fresh figs are ripe?

Look for figs that feel soft and tender with a little give, but aren’t mushy or leaking. Once picked, figs don’t continue to ripen much, so buy them ready to eat

What can I use if fresh figs are out of season?

Fig jam or fig preserves. That’s your move.
Skip the sautéed fig step entirely and spread a thin layer of jam right onto the bread then the whipped goat cheese before the prosciutto goes on. Finish with fresh thyme and pistachios if you’re using them.
It’s not the same as fresh figs, nothing really is, but it means this appetizer doesn’t get benched for ten months of the year.

Not a Goat Cheese Fan?

Whipped feta, whipped ricotta or a soft spreadable Brie would all be delicious with the figs, honey and prosciutto.
Whipped feta will keep that salty, tangy bite, while whipped ricotta is milder and a little lighter. For something rich and buttery, use a soft spreadable Brie. No whipping required with that one. Just spread it right onto the toasted crostini.
But if you do like goat cheese, that’s still my pick. That tang with the warm honey figs and salty prosciutto is just so good.

Do I have to cook the figs?

If your figs are beautifully ripe, you can absolutely use them fresh.
But that quick minute or two in the butter, honey and thyme brings out their sweetness and gives you that warm honey butter to drizzle over the finished crostini.
And I really don’t want you missing out on that drizzle.

One Fig, Finally put to good use

So there you have it. It may have taken me a few decades to recover from our very unsuccessful Long Island fig harvest, but I think we’ve finally redeemed ourselves. This whipped goat cheese crostini with figs and prosciutto is exactly what I want to put out when friends come over this fall.

I have plenty more where this came from. Try my Fall Flatbread for another easy bite to slice up and pass around, my crispy Parmesan Polenta Fries, or one of the most requested fall appetizers around here, my Turkey Wontons.

And there’s plenty more coming. If you want all my new recipes sent straight to your inbox, along with entertaining tips, seasonal menus and whatever else I’m cooking, serving, obsessing over or changing my mind about that week, join the cozy crew.

Print Recipe